Hablamos Español

Asking Hypothetical Questions When Deposing a Defense Expert

Asking Hypothetical Questions When Deposing a Defense Expert

When leading up to a personal injury case, in the discovery phase, defense attorneys will often hire an expert to look into whether the accident at hand caused the plaintiff’s injuries or created problems with preexisting injuries. These defense experts often come back with reports that state the injury or injuries in question were not caused by the accident, or that some treatment was not necessary because the plaintiff should have been pain free at a certain time before that treatment.

In some cases, the defense expert will disagree with a plaintiff’s doctor based on some small scientific facts that require more research. In other cases the defense expert may have looked at certain facts and ignored others to reach their conclusion. In still other cases the medical expert for the defense may have started out with a certain conclusion then looked for facts to support that conclusion in the record.

In cases where the defense expert may have started with a conclusion then looked for facts to support that conclusion, the best way to show that the expert started with a conclusion is in deposition. By using hypothetical questions in depositions, a plaintiff’s attorney can show that the medical expert for the defense is biased or would come to a different conclusion looking at all the facts presented instead of just finding facts to support their conclusions.

When dealing with hypotheticals, a good definition is a question which asks the expert would have given if a set of facts given are assumed true. These kinds of questions can be asked when the expert has an adverse opinion, if, after looking at the expert’s opinion with logical and analytical thought, that the opinion has assumed certain facts, or when there will be evidence that those factual assumptions made by the expert are wrong.

In order to effectively use a hypothetical in a deposition, it is important to set the question up properly. By stating that as an expert, this witness can provide opinion testimony that other witnesses cannot according to the evidence rules, and then stating that you, as an attorney, can ask whether X, Y, and Z are true, and then asking the expert what their opinion would be assuming those facts, is an excellent way to set up the hypothetical. The attorney may then follow up with a statement regarding the truth of those hypothetical facts. Because this is just a hypothetical, the expert does not have to agree that the assumed facts are true, but just has to answer what their opinion would be assuming they are true.

When using hypothetical questions at deposition, make sure the facts fit together well, and that there is little room for the expert to fight those facts. Make sure that they are comprehensive enough that there is a logical conclusion that will flow from them. In this way, when presented with the hypothetical, the expert will find the only logical conclusion to the facts presented and will go with that answer. There might be some minimal pushback, but as long as the attorney has presented the facts in such a way that is fair and as a hypothetical question, there should be very minimal argument from either opposing counsel or the expert.

By using hypothetical questions effectively, a defense expert who holds an adverse opinion should be neutralized in the sense that they have conceded in that hypothetical that their initial opinion was wrong or at the very least the conclusion they came to was one in which they first came to their opinion on the case then looked for facts to support that opinion. A hypothetical question in deposition can ensure that they look at all the facts of the plaintiff’s injuries resulting from a car accident.

Contact Us For a Free Consultation Fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.

    FAQs
    Our Fees

    It cost $0 up front to hire our office. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means you only pay us if we settle your case or obtain a verdict on your behalf.

    If we’re unable to obtain a settlement of verdict for you we eat the costs we’ve advanced to litigate your case, which includes costs for ordering medical records, filing your case, hiring experts, deposing witnesses, and many other things.

    If we do settle your case or obtain a verdict for you our standard rate is 33% of the settlement or verdict, plus reimbursement for the expense we’ve previously advanced. Our fee never increases like some personal injury attorneys, even if we have to take your case to trial.

    Our Fees

    It cost $0 up front to hire our office. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means you only pay us if we settle your case or obtain a verdict on your behalf.

    If we’re unable to obtain a settlement of verdict for you we eat the costs we’ve advanced to litigate your case, which includes costs for ordering medical records, filing your case, hiring experts, deposing witnesses, and many other things.

    If we do settle your case or obtain a verdict for you our standard rate is 33% of the settlement or verdict, plus reimbursement for the expense we’ve previously advanced. Our fee never increases like some personal injury attorneys, even if we have to take your case to trial.

    Case Worth

    As a victim, establishing damages, negotiating with the insurance company, or filing a lawsuit can be daunting and next to impossible without the assistance of an experienced lawyer. As a result, if you have been hurt in an accident, it is important that you contact an attorney as soon as possible to help you recover the compensation to which you are entitled under Indiana law.

    Why Hire?

    Choosing an attorney that has experience dealing with personal injury law is important to protect your legal rights. If you are trying to recover damages from a business or other type of organization, you can bet that they are going to have a legal team on their side.

    Medical Bills

    If you were injured by an accident you may be struggling to determine who is responsible for paying your medical bills and holding them accountable. Speak to an experienced personal injury lawyer at The Law Office of Hurst Limontes LLC and learn if we may be able to help.

    Recovery

    After you have been injured, you are entitled to compensation. The type and amount of compensation depends on the injury, bills, the cause of the injury, negligence/bad faith of the defendant, etc. The attorney you retain can also heavy influence your recovery through knowledge, experience, and dedication. Legal terms and phrases can be confusing even after you retain an attorney. If you have been injured, you may wonder how much your case is worth or what your “damages” are. The worse the injuries, the higher the value of the case and the greater need for an experienced attorney