Hablamos Español

What If The Defendant Gets Rid of Evidence I Need to Prove My Case: Spoliation

Car Accident Lawyers

In a case where evidence has not been preserved by the opposing party, one might have a claim of spoliation of evidence. As defined by Indiana case law, “spoliation of evidence is the intentional destruction, mutilation, alteration, or concealment of evidence – if spoliation by a party to a lawsuit is proved, the jury may infer that the missing evidence was unfavorable to that party.” American Nat. Property and Casualty Co. v. Wilmoth 893 N.E.2d 1068 (Ind. Ct. of Appeals) 2008.

Procedurally, a Preservation of Evidence Request is normally filed first. If the other party does not preserve the evidence, they may be sanctioned by the court for spoliation. This means that a party requesting evidence was told that it was unavailable, or had been lost, or had been destroyed. This can occur if a video recording was not preserved, or an object was thrown away or destroyed. However, the moving party must prove that spoliation has occurred. Spoliation only applies to physical evidence, such as objects, documents, or records pertaining to the case.

Indiana’s court system has also laid out what a party needs to prove in order to succeed on a claim of spoliation. “A party raising a claim of spoliation must prove that (1) there was a duty to preserve the evidence, and (2) the alleged spoliator either negligently or intentionally destroyed, mutilated, altered, or concealed the evidence.” NIPSCO v. Aqua Environmental 102 N.E.3d 290 (Ind. Ct. of Appeals) 2018.

A duty to preserve the evidence would arise if that evidence is necessary in determining cause or fault. For example, in the above cited case, a fire occurred at Aqua Environmental’s warehouse. The cause of the fire was suspected to be a furnace that NIPSCO had installed and maintained. However, while demolishing and fixing the warehouse, Aqua Environmental lost or threw away a piece of the furnace that was necessary to determine if it was the exact cause of the fire. NIPSCO made a claim of spoliation and it was determined that the evidence had negligently been lost by Aqua.

Spoliation claims do not necessarily lead to sanctions. Generally, courts look at two factors to determine if sanctions are viable. The two factors are (1) the degree of culpability of the party who lost or destroyed the evidence, and (2) the degree of actual prejudice to the other party NIPSCO v. Aqua Environmental 102 N.E.3d at 303. Both culpability and prejudice are determined by using a scale to determine the degree of each factor. Determining adequate remedies for spoliation of evidence is left to the trial court.

Spoliation of evidence is unanimously decried by courts as thwarting justice or equitable remedies under the law. When spoliation of evidence occurs, a party is disadvantaged by a sudden lack of evidence it might require in order to try a case. When dealing with spoliation of evidence in a case, a party must ensure that the issue meets the requirements for spoliation of evidence to be established, and they must be able to show they have been prejudiced as a result. It’s important to contact a personal injury lawyer quickly after you’re injured so we can be sure to ask that any necessary evidence be preserved.

Contact Us For a Free Consultation Fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.

FAQs
Our Fees

It cost $0 up front to hire our office. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means you only pay us if we settle your case or obtain a verdict on your behalf.

If we’re unable to obtain a settlement of verdict for you we eat the costs we’ve advanced to litigate your case, which includes costs for ordering medical records, filing your case, hiring experts, deposing witnesses, and many other things.

If we do settle your case or obtain a verdict for you our standard rate is 33% of the settlement or verdict, plus reimbursement for the expense we’ve previously advanced. Our fee never increases like some personal injury attorneys, even if we have to take your case to trial.

Our Fees

It cost $0 up front to hire our office. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means you only pay us if we settle your case or obtain a verdict on your behalf.

If we’re unable to obtain a settlement of verdict for you we eat the costs we’ve advanced to litigate your case, which includes costs for ordering medical records, filing your case, hiring experts, deposing witnesses, and many other things.

If we do settle your case or obtain a verdict for you our standard rate is 33% of the settlement or verdict, plus reimbursement for the expense we’ve previously advanced. Our fee never increases like some personal injury attorneys, even if we have to take your case to trial.

Case Worth

As a victim, establishing damages, negotiating with the insurance company, or filing a lawsuit can be daunting and next to impossible without the assistance of an experienced lawyer. As a result, if you have been hurt in an accident, it is important that you contact an attorney as soon as possible to help you recover the compensation to which you are entitled under Indiana law.

Why Hire?

Choosing an attorney that has experience dealing with personal injury law is important to protect your legal rights. If you are trying to recover damages from a business or other type of organization, you can bet that they are going to have a legal team on their side.

Medical Bills

If you were injured by an accident you may be struggling to determine who is responsible for paying your medical bills and holding them accountable. Speak to an experienced personal injury lawyer at The Law Office of Hurst Limontes LLC and learn if we may be able to help.

Recovery

After you have been injured, you are entitled to compensation. The type and amount of compensation depends on the injury, bills, the cause of the injury, negligence/bad faith of the defendant, etc. The attorney you retain can also heavy influence your recovery through knowledge, experience, and dedication. Legal terms and phrases can be confusing even after you retain an attorney. If you have been injured, you may wonder how much your case is worth or what your “damages” are. The worse the injuries, the higher the value of the case and the greater need for an experienced attorney