How Do I Prove Another Driver Hit My Car?

Indianapolis Personal Injury Law William W. Hurst

When a car accident happens, it’s necessary to establish who was at fault because that party will be liable for the damages they caused. These damages may include personal injuries and property damage. Often those who were involved in the accident or witness to the accident will know who was responsible. However, sometimes, a victim in a car accident has to prove the other party was at fault. If you have been in an accident and need to prove someone else’s liability, take these steps:

Examine the Physical Evidence

The damage to the vehicles may help establish who was at fault. Where was your car hit? Where is their car damaged? What was the result of the impact? If another driver hit your car from behind, or was making a left turn into oncoming traffic, they are very likely to be at fault. While there are some exceptions to those common accident scenarios, the damage to the vehicles is usually enough to prove liability.

Consult Witnesses

Even in cases where fault seems clear, some drivers may attempt to prove that they were not actually responsible for the accident in order to avoid liability. For example:

  • A driver who was turning left into traffic may attempt to prove that the car traveling toward them was moving too fast.
  • A driver who rear-ended a vehicle may suggest that the victim was attempting to reverse their car at a traffic light.

In fact, a victim’s driving mistakes, such as missing tail lights or miscalculated timing when approaching an intersection, can reduce the other party’s liability. In cases where there is shared fault the amount a party may have to pay for damages will be reduced, giving them an incentive to try to prove exactly that. To challenge this tactic, produce witness reports and testimony that can corroborate your claim that the other party was at fault.

Check the Police Report

Depending on the severity of the accident, police may have come to the scene to make a report and take statements. Even if the accident was minor and there were no injuries, the involved parties are still responsible for making a police report to the appropriate authorities as soon as possible.

The police report can help establish liability and prove who was at fault, which is essential for filing a claim with an insurance company. However, be aware that police reports can be inaccurate. Review your report after it is made, and if there is an error, correct it as soon as possible to ensure the true circumstances of the accident are officially documented.

Look for Additional Evidence

If the evidence at the scene isn’t conclusive and the other driver refuses to admit fault, you may need to look for other evidence. Determine if any municipal traffic cameras or commercial cameras from nearby businesses recorded the accident. Such recorded footage can be key evidence for establishing fault.

Get Legal Help After Your Indianapolis Accident—Call William W. Hurst Today!

If you were in an accident in Indiana and you’re struggling to establish the other party’s liability, speak to an experienced personal injury lawyer at The Law Office of William W. Hurst and learn if we may be able to help. Contact us today at (317) 636-0808 or online for a free consultation.

28 Nov

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn If you have been in a semi truck accident, you may have large medical expenses and other damages, from property loss to pain and suffering. The burden of being in an accident may be compounded by having to deal with a difficult insurance company to negotiate a settlement. How can you…

20 Nov

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Most motor vehicle accidents have straightforward liability. For example, when two privately owned cars collide in an intersection, the driver who entered against the lights will be liable for the damages they caused to the other driver. When an accident involves other types of vehicles, such as a bus, issues such…

16 Nov

Accident Forgiveness

By Bill Hurst

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Accident Forgiveness is a program offered by insurance companies that ensures rates will not increase after your first at-fault car accident. To determine if you need or want accident forgiveness coverage, you should know what it is, if there is a cost benefit, and whether you are eligible for the program….

Indianapolis Personal Injury Law William W. Hurst
William W. Hurst

Bill Hurst has successfully represented hundreds of accident victims, and has limited his practice to personal injury cases for over thirty-five (35) years.


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share This